• Log In
  • Log In
Science Leadership Academy @ Center City
Science Leadership Academy @ Center City Learn · Create · Lead
  • Students
    • Mission and Vision
  • Parents
  • Community
    • Mission and Vision
  • Calendar

World History - Block - C Public Feed

Create a Post

Pipeline Monologue Project

Posted by Kara Rosenberg in World History - Block - C on Wednesday, October 2, 2013 at 7:50 pm

In this unit, our class learned about the Keystone Pipeline, and the arguments for and against it. The Keystone Pipeline is a pitched idea of a pipe that carries tar sand's oil from Canada to Texas. This pipe will go through six states to get to Texas, which could potentially affect peoples' land and lives. The decision of whether this pipeline will be passed is made by Barack Obama. 


Quotes and facts:

"The Keystone XL pipeline would carry 830,000 barrels of dirty tar sands oil into the United States daily, and result in climate-damaging emissions equal to adding more than 5.6 million new cars to U.S. roads. " foe.org

"During tar sands oil production alone, levels of carbon dioxide emissions are three to four times higher than those of conventional oil." foe.org

"The probability of spills from this pipeline is high and more threatening than conventional spills, because tar sands oil sinks rather than floats, making clean ups more difficult and costly." foe.org

"In the summer of 2010, a million gallons of tar sands oil poured into the Kalamazoo River in Michigan from a pipeline run by another Canadian company, Enbridge. Although nearly one billion dollars have been spent over the past three years to clean up the spill, almost 40 miles of the river are still contaminated." foe.org

"Not only have indigenous communities been forced off of their land, but also those living downstream from tailing ponds have seen spikes in rates of rare cancers, renal failure, lupus, and hyperthyroidism." foe.org


Memoirs 

STORY 1

(Sitting in doctors office waiting, doctor comes into the room)

Hi Doctor Miles, I’m good thanks. And you? Oh thats great. Yeah, yeah, the baby is doing fine as far as I’m concerned, I feel great!

(Doctor begins to take tests)

So do you see anything I should be worried about? Oh that’s wonderful. Just two more months to go, I’m so excited! I’ve always dreamed about raising my daughter in the same place I grew up… She’s actually going to have the room I had when I was little! Yeah, I’m really excited. Well, is there anything else? My asthma? It’s alright I guess, I mean I just got used to it. Yeah, I mean I’ve had it my whole life, most of my siblings have it, too, It’s just normal for me. No, my husband doesn’t have it but his mother and grandmother do. Well, I mean I’ve never thought about it before, but I mean I would know how to handle it if my daughter did end up having asthma. No, I know, I understand. You’re concerned? Concerned about what? Yeah, I live about a mile away from here, why? I’ve heard about it in the news, one of my sister’s friend’s land is going to be affected by the pipeline, boy is she mad. My opinion? I don’t know, I’m kind of sidetracked by the baby, I haven’t really had time to think about anything else, is there something wrong with that? I would figure it would cause some pollution… Are you telling me my house will be affected, too? Really? Do you think my asthma will start acting up again? Wow, I’ve never thought about it that way. Lets hope my daughter won’t end up having it! Yeah I know, I’m just trying to be optimistic. So what should I do if she does get it, what if the pipeline is passed? I can’t just get up and move Doctor, this is my home! I grew up here! I am calm! I’m calm. It’s just, I never thought I’d move, especially not because I’m getting polluted out of my own home. Well, thanks for the advice. I really have to go… I have a lot to think about.


STORY 2

(Sitting at kitchen table reading the paper. Loud sounds from video games coming from the basement)

“Turn that down, Jacob! Jacob! I said turn it down! It’s gotta be quieter than that! You’ll wake up your mother!” Geez… I can hardly hear myself think. One of these days you’re going to have to just tell him to get out. But he’s my son… What am I going to do? No. He’s 26 years old. I shouldn’t have to deal with this anymore. But he’s my son… No. He needs to know that our door is always open… But-but not unless you actually do something for a change! You can’t just sit around, play video games, eat all the food, make a mess, and expect me to pay for all of it. I don’t think so. He’s not even trying to find a job! He thinks this is a free ride. Oh no. No, no, no. This can’t go on any longer. (Flips to article on protesting of the Keystone Pipeline) Oh, God, not this again. Who cares? If its makin’ new jobs, its fine by me. This is what I need, this is what America needs! This is the one thing thats gonna get my son out of my house, fending for himself. Anything that does that is okay in my book. God knows he needs this. (Checks watch) 12:30 already? Man, its late. (Goes to stove and puts a kettle on the stove. Makes a plate of food on a tray. Makes a cup of tea with the water. Walks upstairs and quietly goes into his room to see his sleeping wife.) -sighs- Still asleep… Of course. (Walks over to the bed and puts tray of food on the nightstand. Sits on foot of the bed.) -Talking quietly- “You’re so beautiful when you sleep. Man, do I really miss you. I mean… I really miss you. Thats silly to say, you’re right here in front of me. I guess I just mean…. I mean… We used to have so much fun. Remember when we used to go bowling with the Andersons every Sunday night? Ha- I miss them. I remember I’d come home from work every day, and Jacob would be doing his homework, and you’d have dinner on the table and dessert in the oven. You were really great. You still are. I love you. I love you so much. Its just that… (sniffles, wipes tear from cheek) I never thought this day would come so fast. I’m sorry I can’t do more for you… I wish I could take you to the best doctor in the world and he’d fix you, and we’d be back to normal! Its just so hard, you know, with Jacob here and all. Its a lot of people I have to take care of on my own without any help. But don’t you worry, soon Jacob will be working on the pipeline! I just know it. And I’ll be able to afford a doctor for you… and we can be happy again. I promise. I love you.”

STORY 3

(Sitting at computer in robe, coffee in hand)

Ah, lets see… Wow! Five new likes on my post overnight! Well, I’m glad to see some people care… unlike you 27 people who dislike my post. Pff. If only you knew what was really going on… If you would just take the time to listen, and open your hearts to what the environment is telling you… You’d understand. You wouldn’t need me, you would only need yourself. (Reading aloud) “Dear Stacy, what a wonderful piece you have written on the Keystone Pipeline! Please, come to Boston! I know we’d love to hear you talk! Love, Miranda.” Aw, how sweet. Dear Miranda, thanks so much! Love to see that you care. Best wishes, Stacy. Maybe I should think about doing another seminar… I’ve only been to Boston once. Maybe that’d be fun. (Reading aloud) “Stacy, why don’t you just shut up already. Go back to the 80’s. This is 2013, we’re advancing technology everyday. This pipeline is exactly what we need to get ourselves out of this rut, and anyone who thinks otherwise isn’t American. -Anonymous” Wow. Just. Okay. Wow. Remember Stacy… be professional. The world can see this. Maybe I should just delete the comment. No, big deal, act like it was never there. No! I can’t run from my problems. I need to face them. You are smarter than this person, you are more mature. Okay. (Reading aloud) “Dear anonymous, I appreciate the criticism but I’m afraid you are wrong…” No, no, no. Thats just pointing fingers. You need to stick to an actual argument. Lets see “Dear anonymous, thanks for the criticism, but I would have to disagree. What is the point of being American if soon we’re just going to end up destroying the world, meaning the US is gone?!-” Now thats just too harsh. I’ve never had someone be so against my opinions… Okay, lets try again. “Dear Anonymous, thanks for the criticism, but I have to disagree. Since when is being American about destroying our Earth? The Earth was never built to have so much pollution in it, let alone so many people! We are the ones causing these problems. The Earth is not meant to have a gigantic pipe carrying disgusting toxins through it. It’s one thing to give off pollution into the atmosphere, but this is literally putting toxins directly into our ground. I get the positive points to it, don’t get me wrong, it creates new jobs, makes our country more independant, so on and so forth. But since when is economics more important than taking care of the place we live. If we keep neglecting the Earth, one day you’ll wake up and see there is no point to having all of this money if we don’t have anywhere to spend it… Our world is crumbling to pieces every day, you’re just too blind to see it.”


Monologues from Kara Rosenberg on Vimeo.

Be the first to comment.

Pipeline Monologue Project

Posted by Elizabeth Vellozzi in World History - Block - C on Wednesday, October 2, 2013 at 7:49 pm

Part I

This unit was all about how the world is an equal place the attempts to make it better. We saw that the UN had plans to make the world an all around better place by 2015, but that it really wasn’t gone about the right way. A specific plan to make the world a more equal place was the plan for the Keystone Pipeline. This is a system through which crude oil is delivered from Alberta, Canada and Northern United States. There are many pros and cons that go along with this plan which is why it’s been debated for about five years. To list some of the pros theres, jobs being created by the pipeline, new found revenue from taxes, and not to mention less dependence on foreign oil. On the other hand, as a country, we really don’t have any money to spend on a pipeline. Plus, if something goes wrong with the pipe itself it can pollute countless drinking water sources. 



Part II

  • Cancer can be one of the effects of installing the pipeline
  • (Tar Sands Action) Gas prices will increase if Keystone Pipeline is put into affect 
  • (National Wildlife Federation) TransCanada’s Keystone XL would carry up to 830,000 barrels per day of tar sands oil
  • (National Wildlife Federation) The pipeline would cross six American states including Montana, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma and Texas.
  • (Natural Resources Defense Council) Has already created over 65 square miles of toxic waste
    ponds


Part III

Monologue #1 (A Cup-a Caw-fee and a Pipeline)

(Opens with Connie pouring her friend Stella a cup of coffee)


The people on the news said it would create jobs so uh therefor I think it is a very good plan


Whatayou mean ‘what do I care about jobs?’ Why shouldn’t I care?


No I’m not workin’ smart ass but ya know my grandchildren, my beautiful grandchil-- wait a minute look at this, hold on lemme get it outta my pocka-book Carla just sent me a new picture of kids look at that.


(Grabs photo and shows it to Stella) 


Yeaaaah thank you yes they are very adorable


(Puts photo away while saying)


Anyway yeah they're brilliant kids I'm tellin ya and I want them to have jobs cuz they're brilliant i'm tellin ya. 


They're 5 and 3, little Vinny’s 3 yeah. 


Well I mean in the future I want them to have jobs. When I am no longer here I would like them to have stability. 


What do ya mean it causes cancer howz it do that


Well if you don’t know how you gonna tell me it causes cancer, ya know thats serious business that cancer uh ya want more coffee?


You sure? I got plenty


Carla just brought me two bags of that uh fancy starbucks grind


I got those international creamer things 


White chawc-a-let (chocolate) macadamia


Well alright suit cha self now uh where did you hear all this bologna about cancer?


Yeah you just saw it on the news. Ya know you can’t always rely on the news people these days


Yeah I got my information from the news but I watch channel 3 you watch channel 10 that damn weatherman with the bow tie never gets anything right what’s his name thunderstorm Shwartz or somethin


Hurricane? Yeah Hurricane Shwartz whatever I’m tell ya this pipe is a good thing


(Bangs pointer finger on table while saying)


Whataya mean we don’t have the money? We got money this is the United States of America we got everything. Freedom, that cutie Justin uh what’s his name uh TIMBALAKE.


No you cannot tell me what goes on behind those walls cause no one knows but them for all we know we could be rollin’ in money! Ya sound like friggen liberal have a little faith in ya govament will ya jesus christ!


I’m not gettin’ worked up I’m sayin


Oh Christ it’s already four o'clock I gotta start the gravy


(Gets up and walks in the kitchen)


Oh you’re still on this friggen pipe thing?


No Stell-- Stella! They’re in office for a reason I’m tellin ya


Stella I’m sure they have picked a perfectly suitable person to make the damn thing


Oh here we go its not gonna break ya know you’re makin me sorry I even brought it up just let me make my gravy will ya

 

Ya know what you're making me even confused than when I was 10 minutes ago just eat cha danish I’m all discombobulated



Monologue #2 Designing Disaster

(Opens with Jason at his desk sighing and digging his fingers in his temples)


(Protest chants ringing outside the office building)


Holly! Hollyyy! Holly!


(Assistant runs in)


Is there any way you can get those people to go bother someone else!? It’s hard enough getting any work done with the big bosses and the damn Canadians breathing down my neck waiting for the perfect plan for the god damn pipeline!


No I apologize, I’m yelling at the wrong person.


Thank you. Can you maybe get me an extra extra large coffee with extra extra bourbon?


Yeah yeah I know


(mumbles to himself)


Jesus I was just kidding lighten up


(Starts talking to himself as Jennifer exits the room)


I got people pulling me from each end for years about this damn thing! It creates jobs but we have no money to begin with. It might cause water pollution but it brings in revenue.


(Chanting outside gets louder)


(Jumps out of his chair and shouts through glass window)


Oh will you people just give it a rest already! Jesus Christ I can’t even hear myself think!


(Turns back around to his desk) 


This job is gonna give me a full head of gray hair before my 35th birthday. Essentially I’m choosing between designing something that causes cancer or bailing on a project that can help the economy, feed my family, and further my career.


(Looks up)


What did I do to deserve this? This could be classifiable as torture. I have the mental and emotional stability of a hormonal pregnant woman.


If I’m actually as good of an architect as everyone thinks I am I should be able to design this thing so that it doesn’t break. Right? Of course I can. Yeah, all I have to do is stop thinking like a wuss. Come on Jay,man up and build this thing like its nobodys business. If I pull this off no one gets cancer, the economy has a chance to get back on its feet, but most importantly all the prestige that will come with being the hero of this whole situation. I can do this. Yeah, I can do this. Woo. alright. Jen! Call the big guys and tell em I’m in.



Monologue #3 The Bitter Brit

(Opens on an English man and his wife in the their home in Briton)

(Plops on chair in front of the television and is yelling to his wife in the kitchen about what he’s seeing on the news)


Oy! Darling have you seen this oil rig in Canada and America?


America made a big to-do about this pipeline from there to Canada for Oil. The country is 74x times England for Christ’s sake and all they do is complain. They’re the spoiled brat of the world.


I’m not bitter I’m just saying it causes cancer and they’re still thinking about building the bloody thing because it’ll make them more money.


Well it’s their own fault if they don’t have money 


Look all I’m saying is that if they had a couple Brits in office they’d whip that country back into shape in no time.


I mean hun come here look at this. This thing costs four billion Euros! That’s just ridiculous!


Well yeah it’s not ALL bad I mean they can put a tiny band-aid on their economy but if the damn thing kills everyone they wont care about the economy!


If there’s ever a time to be proud to be a Brit it’s now. They’ve been griping and groaning about this pipeline for 5 years.


Oh I need a nice British ale.


(Gets up and walks in the kitchen)

(When returning to living room grunts as he sits back in his chair and mumbles to himself)


Seventy four times bigger! Ungrateful berks.  


I’m not bitter. It just seems like it’s an obvious choice. Just don’t build the bloody thing. They can find some other way to get their money I mean do they have no care for their own citizens?


Alright Alright I know I’m sorry. I know I’m getting worked up. I know I’m changing the channel. Not my problem. I’ll just stay here in my tiny country.

A Cup-a Caw-fee and a Pipeline from Elizabeth Vellozzi on Vimeo.

Be the first to comment.

Pipeline Monologue Project

Posted by Myrna Yousuf in World History - Block - C on Wednesday, October 2, 2013 at 7:17 pm

​In this unit we learned about how the building of the Keystone Pipeline has caused a lot of controversies. This pipeline is a project that is about creating a pipeline from Canada through the United States reaching down to the Gulf Of Mexico. By doing so we will be receiving tar sands oil from Canada. We discussed the pros and cons of this in class. In this Monologue Project I present the ideas of three different people who see this in different perspectives.

Five Quotes
  • "will create “about 20,000 construction and manufacturing jobs”

    http://www.pbs.org/wnet/need-to-know/five-things/the-keystone-xl-pipeline/12200/


  • "With an anticipated decision on the Presidential Permit in 2013, the Keystone XL Pipeline has a projected in-service date of 2015."

    http://keystone-xl.com/?gclid=CMeWqOmh5LkCFcyZ4AodKhQAdw


  • TransCanada is currently employing 4,000 Americans in Oklahoma and Texas on construction of the $2.3-billion Gulf Coast Pipeline Project, which is expected to be complete by the end of this year. 

    http://keystone-xl.com/?gclid=CMeWqOmh5LkCFcyZ4AodKhQAdw       

  • The pipelines will also generate an estimated $5 billion in additional property taxes during their operational life. 

    http://keystone-xl.com/?gclid=CMeWqOmh5LkCFcyZ4AodKhQAdw       
  • Numerous studies have shown that crude oil produced from Canada’s oil sands pose no additional safety risks to pipelines and have a similar carbon footprint to other heavy crude oils from around the world. 
              http://keystone-xl.com/?gclid=CMeWqOmh5LkCFcyZ4AodKhQAdw       

The Pipeline Job

(Sitting on the couch, tapping the remote)

Darn it these channels don’t even work! This remote needs some new batteries or somethin’. Allieee! Alliee! What does a guy have to do to watch some TV aroun’ here? Ah there we go, finally its workin’. What’s this? What kind of mess is this? What kind of contraptions do these people be making nowadays? Allie! Come look at this! A fuzzy steering wheel! Who on earth buys them! Ain’t got nothing better to do with their money. I don’t got time for this! Need to see what else is on.

(Clicking the remote)

Nope. No. Oh not again! N- Wait. Ah the news. Oh that pipeline thing they been talking about. I think its a great idea. Hey Allie! Look ‘ere this is what I meant! This could be it for me.

(Allie walks in talking.)

(Jumps up excitedly)

What you mean some other job? It’s perfect. All I need if for that darn pipeline to be built and I could land me a job! I be outta your place before you know it!

(Allie has a worried look on her face.)

You ‘aint got nothin’ to worry about Allie! This is gonna be great! It’s going to help thousands of people land jobs! I’m gonna be one of them.

Allie Allie Allie, you don’t get it. I like to work out in the open. I don’t wanna be taking peoples orders and faking how happy I am, just so I could get a decent tip. No way! That pipeline is gonna be built. It’s all about the government. A few people can’t do nothing.



Protesting the Pipeline

(Shouting at protesters in the background)

Say no to the Pipeline! Say no to the Pipeline! Tar sand will pollute our land! It’ll destroy our forests!

(Walks out of the crowd of protesters)

We’ve been at it for so long. I don’t even know if our voices are going to heard and considered. All the government wants is business. They haven’t even thought about the effects on people. What about the environment? All they want is their stupid business.

(Jacks friend agreeing with him. Nods his head.)

(Jack raises his fist.)

Exactly what I was thinking. I mean there are so many points to be taken into account but they are just ignored. I can list so many things that are being ignored. The carbon emissions are 3 to 4 times more in just the tar sand oil production than regular oil. Just imagine the amount of damage that is going to cause to our environment. Even to just clean out the dirty substances are going to cost us. These substances can get into our clean water supplies. Who’s worrying about that? No one. Just us reasonable people trying to somehow stop this.

I mean no one worries about this stuff. The media doesn’t even cover the effects of this pipeline. No one cares until there problems that start occurring afterwards. What is going to happen to my kids if the water gets contaminated. Do I just let that happen first and then receive benefits for their sickness? This is not a joking matter. Not only for the people here but it is also a danger for my family. We are going to be the ones going through this mess. We need to stop it before it actually causes damage to us and our loved ones. There is no point in taking risks.

(Jacks friend continues to discuss with him.)

I just hope this pipeline isn’t built. It isn’t going to be good for any of us. I mean its one of the most dirtiest fuels on Earth. Why can’t we invest and work on other alternatives for our fuel? Break time is up lets go back now.

(Heads back to crowd of protesters.)


A Native American on the Pipeline

Ahh this breeze feels so good. Just like those good old times I used to watch the birds. But its not the same anymore. Doesn’t have the same earthy smell. Its contaminated, polluted, tainted. Things are just not the same anymore.

(A boy come in yelling something at Nadie.)

Oh yeah. I saw some stuff about some kind of pipeline is going to be built from Canada. What you mean through here? I am not going to give up my land again to these people.

(Yells back to Nadie.)

Who do they think they are they can just come through my land and stick a pipe through it. That’s what these darn Americans know how to do. All they do is invade and take everything from us. I’ve had enough. I sure as heck won’t allow this. They just better find some other way to get their stupid contraption through. They just always worry about their benefits and not about the people. My people have been here for so long and we had moved here so that we could get a peaceful place to stay. But now I see they just keep pushing us around. I’m not letting this happen.

(Rocking back and forth on his chair)

(Waving his hand around as he speaks.)

Boy what are you talking about. I sure as heck am not going to allow their stupid oil down my property; and I am definitely not going to be kicked out! Talking about being used to this. Huh! They just wish I’d give up that easy. Puh! I’ll be waiting here for them. Those men with those fancy clothes trying to get me to sign those papers. Over my dead body. Those conniving people. What good is getting more oil gonna do for them?

(The boy speaks urgently.)

Boy you don’t know anything. That hasn’t stopped these people from taking away things. They took away our lands and our homes, now they want to repeat that.

The foreign oil is also something else. So what? Haven’t they been getting their stupid oil all these years from them.

(Stamps his foot on the floor.)

What now, is that oil contaminated or something? They got a problem with the foreigners now! We sure as heck have problems with them. What happened when they barged into our homes and kicked us out? They are the foreigners! Stupid, dumb government. Huh! Going through my land. I think not! Now you go on off boy. No more nonsense about this pipeline.

Pipeline Monologue Project from myousuf on Vimeo.

Be the first to comment.
73 posts:
← Prev
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
RSS

WRLDHIST-014

Term
2013-14

Other Websites

Launch Canvas

Blog Tags

  • digital story 9
  • revolution 9
  • Block World History 10 1

Teacher

  • Joshua Block
Science Leadership Academy @ Center City · Location: 1482 Green St · Shipping: 550 N. Broad St Suite 202 · Philadelphia, PA 19130 · (215) 400-7830 (phone)
×

Log In